Name Your Price·Make an offer on any piece·Until Sunday 15 November·BrowseUntil Sunday 15 NovFinal day·Offers close at midnight UK (7pm New York)
Edwardian diamond snake ring, Chester 1913, 18K gold with old cut diamonds

How to Authenticate Antique Jewellery Before You Buy (and Spot Fakes Online)

How do you know antique jewellery is genuine before you buy it? Look at three things together: how it was made, what its marks and stones say, and whether the seller stands behind the description in writing. No single test settles it. A real antique tells a consistent story, from its construction and wear to its hallmarks and gemstones, and a good dealer will show you that story rather than ask you to take it on trust.

In brief

  • Construction, wear, marks and stones should all agree on the same date.
  • Hallmarks help, but many genuine antiques are unmarked; metal testing fills the gap.
  • Paste, doublets and later mounts are not fakes if they are clearly described.
  • Buy online only with clear photographs, a written condition report and a returns policy.

What "authentic" really means in antique jewellery

Authenticity is not just "old or new". A piece can be entirely of one period; it can be an antique jewel that has been altered, resized or remounted; or it can be a modern piece made to look old. All three exist, and the first two can be wonderful things to own.

What matters is that the description matches the object. An honest listing tells you which parts are original, which are later, and what each stone and metal is. The problems begin when a modern piece is sold as period, or a later alteration goes unmentioned.

1. Read the hallmarks, then check they make sense

Hallmarks are the most useful single clue, where they exist. A full British set gives the maker's mark, the gold standard, the assay office and a date letter. Together they can date a piece to the year and tell you who made it.

Our Edwardian Diamond Snake Ring is a textbook example. It is fully hallmarked for 18K gold, with the Chester assay mark, the date letter for 1913 and the maker's mark J.G. Its old cut diamonds, its weight and its light, even wear all agree with that date.

Edwardian diamond snake ring, Chester 1913, 18K gold with old cut diamonds
Edwardian Diamond Snake Ring, Chester, 1913

That agreement is the real test. Marks can be worn, misread or, occasionally, added later, so they should always fit the style, the stones and the construction. A "Georgian" ring with a crisp modern stamp and a modern brilliant cut diamond deserves a second look.

When there is no hallmark

The absence of a mark is not a warning sign in itself. Many Georgian and Victorian jewels were never sent for assay, and small pieces were often exempt. In those cases a reputable dealer tests the metal and says so in the description. Our guide to antique jewellery eras explains how marks and styles changed over time.

2. Look at how it was made

Construction is harder to fake than a mark. Before about 1900, most fine jewellery was made by hand: settings were built up piece by piece, claws were individually formed and stones were often set in closed backs. Modern copies tend to be cast in one piece, with soft detail, tiny pits in the metal and uniform, machine-like finishing.

The Georgian Diamond Floral Cluster of around 1780 shows the hallmarks of period work. Its rose cut diamonds sit in closed, foil-backed silver settings on an 18K gold band, a construction typical of the 18th century. It also carries French import marks, the owl for gold and the swan for silver, showing it passed through French assay at a later date.

Georgian rose cut diamond floral cluster ring, c.1780, 18K gold and silver
Georgian Diamond Floral Cluster, c.1780

Its listing also notes patina, surface wear and the slight irregularities of hand construction. Those are exactly the signs you hope to see. Wear should fall where a piece is handled and rubbed, such as the back of a shank or the high points of a setting, not spread evenly as if tumbled.

3. Know what the stones are

Stone identification is where most confusion arises. Antique jewellery uses natural gemstones, but also paste (hand-cut glass), doublets (a thin gem top on a glass base) and, from the early 20th century, synthetic rubies and sapphires. None of these is a fake in itself. They become a problem only when sold as something they are not.

Paste is a good example. The Antique French Pink Paste Solitaire of the mid-19th century centres on a raspberry-pink paste stone in a silver gallery with fleur-de-lis claws, on an 18K gold band with French control marks. It is described plainly as paste, which is precisely why you can buy it with confidence.

Antique French pink paste solitaire ring, mid-19th century, 18K gold and silver
Antique French Pink Paste Solitaire, mid-19th century

Fine paste was worn at court in the 18th century and is collected in its own right today. Old cut diamonds have their own tell-tale features too, from the high crown to the small open culet; our guide to rose cut diamond rings explains what to look for.

When a gem certificate matters

For an important coloured stone, an independent laboratory report adds real certainty. It confirms the species, whether the stone is natural, and whether it has been heat-treated, and it can sometimes indicate origin. These questions cannot be settled by eye.

Our Belle Époque Burma Spinel Cluster of around 1900 is a case in point. Its 1.8ct natural spinel comes with a GCS certificate confirming Burmese origin and no heat treatment, framed by twelve old mine cut diamonds in platinum-topped settings on 21K gold.

Belle Époque Burma spinel and old mine cut diamond cluster ring, c.1900, 21K gold and platinum
Belle Époque Burma Spinel Cluster, c.1900

4. Check whether every part is the same age

Many antique jewels have been remounted at some point. A Georgian intaglio may sit in a Victorian ring; a brooch may have become a pendant. These "second lives" are common and often charming, as our article on converted antique jewellery shows. The key is that the description says so.

The Gemma Stosch Glass Intaglio Ring is a good model of honest cataloguing. The red glass intaglio is a late 18th-century Grand Tour copy of a famous Etruscan gem, while the 9K gold ring is hallmarked London 1986. Both dates are stated, so you know exactly which part is antique.

Gemma Stosch glass intaglio, late 18th century, in a 9K gold ring of 1986
Gemma Stosch Glass Intaglio Ring

5. Ancient and medieval pieces: ask for parallels

The earlier the piece, the more authentication rests on expertise and comparison. For ancient and medieval rings, look for a dealer who cites comparable examples in museum collections, gives the metal's tested purity and describes the condition frankly.

Our Small Roman Gold Intaglio Ring of about the 1st century BC tests as approximately 23K gold and is set with a banded agate intaglio of a bearded man. Its listing names close parallels in the V&A, the British Museum and the Metropolitan Museum, so you can check the type for yourself.

Ancient Roman gold and banded agate intaglio ring, c.1st century BC
Small Roman Gold Intaglio Ring, c.1st century BC

Our guide to buying a genuine ancient Roman ring goes into more detail, and you can browse more early pieces in our ancient rings collection.

How to spot fakes when buying antique jewelry online

Most people now buy online, so the listing has to do the work your eyes and hands would do in person. A trustworthy listing is detailed and specific. Be cautious when you see any of the following.

  • Few or blurry photographs. You should see the front, sides, back, marks and inside of the shank.
  • Vague dating. "Antique style", "vintage look" or "old" with no period or reasoning.
  • No measurements or weight. Genuine sellers record size, dimensions and grams.
  • Unidentified stones. "Red stone" or "diamond-like" without saying what it is.
  • The same piece many times over. True antiques are almost always one of a kind.
  • No condition notes and no returns. Every old piece has some wear, and a confident seller lets you return it.

A reverse image search of the main photograph is a quick check. If identical "antiques" appear across many sites, walk away.

What a trustworthy dealer should give you

The simplest protection is to buy from a specialist who puts everything in writing. Expect a full description with date, origin, metal (marked or tested), stone identification, measurements and weight, plus an honest condition report that notes any repairs, resizing or later parts.

That is how we describe every piece of antique jewelry we sell, with a returns policy behind it. Our guide to how to value an antique ring explains what drives the price once you know a piece is right. You can also browse our Georgian and Edwardian collections, or see pieces in person at our showroom in Shoreditch, by appointment.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if antique jewellery is real gold?

Look for a hallmark or a purity stamp such as 18, 750 or 585, and check it suits the piece's style and date. If there is no mark, a jeweller can test the metal. A reputable dealer will state the result of that test in the description.

Is unmarked antique jewellery fake?

No. A great deal of genuine Georgian and Victorian jewellery was never hallmarked, and small items were often exempt. Construction, wear and metal testing are the better guides for unmarked pieces.

Is paste jewellery fake?

Not when it is sold as paste. Antique paste is hand-cut glass that was a fashionable luxury in its own day, and it is collected for its craftsmanship. It is only a problem if it is described as a gemstone.

Do I need a certificate for antique jewellery?

For most pieces, a detailed written description and condition report from a reputable dealer are enough. For important coloured stones or large diamonds, an independent laboratory report adds certainty about the stone's identity and treatment.

Article précédent